BlueAnt X5 bluetooth stereo headset
Written by Kelsey   
Tuesday, 02 January 2007
I'm a card-carrying gadget freak, so it's no suprise I've been on the lookout for a decent bluetooth stereo headset for some time.

Despite an allure of near gravitational proportions, I've never really been able to justify getting an in-ear bluetooth headset. It's a lot of fuss (plus a piece of flashing plastic sticking out of my ear) to alleviate the task of picking up my phone - something I find not too onerous.

Bluetooth stereo headsets are another matter. I like the idea of wireless audio, able to get up from my computer or leave my iPod beyond the reach of its white tether. I also cycle hundreds of kilometres a week, and the iPod headphone cable can be a bother. A crucial factor, however, is that I can't hear my phone when my headphones are on.

So for me, a killer product is one that will:

  1. Wirelessly stream audio from my iPod or computer
  2. Pair with my phone to deliver calls on demand
Currently there are two products on the market that deliver, the Plantronics Pulsar 590 series and the BlueAnt X5. While I'll also give a review of the Plantronics in a few days, I chose the X5's.

My thoughts after the jump:
After obsessing over this decision for a while, it eventually came down to one small factor that tipped my choice in favour of BlueAnt - I love behind-the-neck headphones.

One thing I won't cover in detail is the audio quality. For me, headphones are about mobile enjoyment rather than perfection of sound. I have a great sound system when I'm feeling indulgent and I don't expect or need headphones to attempt to match that. I should also point out that I graduated from the Queensland Conservatorium of Music as an Opera major - so I've got pretentious music twaddle available on demand.

Auditory street-cred established, it should suffice to say that when streaming stereo music, they're absolutely fine and I was surprised at just how good they sounded listening both iPod and computer.

The Good

  • Uncharacteristically generous accessorisation - the container includes some nice thoughtfull extras, such as the foam speaker covers, two USB charging cables, mains charger, stereo cable and Y-cable (for VOIP applications).
  • Easy setup - just charge, pair and play. The pairing process for both the included audio streamer and mobile devices is simple and fast. After charging, I was paired and chatting almost instantly.
  • Good quality stereo
  • Comfortable ride - I can wear this headset for hours thanks to the behind-the-neck style.
  • Compact size - the headset folds down to a very small size
  • Good battery life - no extensive testing here, but standby mode is about 200hrs. Listening mode lasts longer than the battery on my iPod - which is all it needs to do.
The Bad
  • Absolutely will not work with OS X without the streamer as the OS doesn't support the A2DP profile. Not BlueAnt's fault and the streamer does a fine job - just looking forward to OS X 10.5 which will support A2DP.
  • Terrible, horrific buzzing noise in the headphones when the streamer is charging.
  • Microphone is badly placed - the one thing I really liked about the Plantronics was its classy-looking telescoping mic. This mike is both a little flimsy and badly placed and oddly shaped for behind-the-neck headphones. I'll explain why further on.
  • Can't charge the headphones and use the mic - the mic uses the same USB port for charging.
  • Can't charge the batteries unless they're on the streamer or headphones - you can purchase spare batteries from BlueAnt - but you can only charge them on the devices, leading to a catch-22 situation where you're unable to use the full feature-set of the device while its charging.
  • Slight delay when using the streamer can be slightly disconcerting if you're watching a movie - but you won't notice it if there's nothing visual the audio is supposed to synch to.
  • No travel case.

The microphone is a chunk of plastic with a USB plug in one end. It's a little flimsy, but that probably wouldn't be as big a problem if it weren't positioned at the bottom of the headset speaker. Why is this a problem? Because one of the advantages of behind-the-neck style headphones is that when you're not listening to them, they're easy to slip off and wear around you neck. But the microphone juts out and rests on your collarbone. It's not uncomfortable, but I worry that this will damage the mic or its connections. I'd like to see BlueAnt offer an alternative mic that sat flatter along the bottom of the speaker.

Even better would be to see V2 of the X5s have USB ports on the batteries for easy charging of spares and a more discrete integrated mic, such as on the plantronics.

Quick tip: For better bass response, it's best to remove the standard leather speaker covers and use the included foam covers instead. It may also give your ears a slightly easier ride.

Using the X5
I've been playing with the X5 for a week now and in general I'm thrilled with it. With the streamer plugged into my iPod and the headset also paired to my phone, I can wander with my beats to my heart's content, secure in the knowledge I won't miss a call. While I don't use it as much as I expected for VOIP, I suspect this will change when OS X "Leopard" is released and the A2DP profile is supported. The headset is light, stylish and the audio quality is surprisingly good. It may take a little while to get used to what the indicator lights mean, but the documentation is good and has some very nice charts to refer to, making interpretating of the blue and red flashes far simpler.
 

About thinksync

We're designers. We're not going to blather on about our design philosophy or methods (there'll be enough of that in the blog).

We design websites, create beautiful printed work and build web applications.

It's what we do, what we love and we're here to help.

Current Projects

Web Design

abstract_no_standing.jpgNo Standing dot com - the blog of Rob Stevens.
Read more...
 

Print Design

peter_sheehan_abstract.png Print projects coming soon!
 

Web Applications

profile_abstract.png Profile ›› innovative eMarketing
Read more...
 

Get in touch

 
 
 

Or get in touch directly:

thinksync
0410579149
This email address is being protected from spam bots, you need Javascript enabled to view it